Webbing…

September 28th, 2009  |  Published in Gear  |  2 Comments

webbingSlackline is different from tightrope, tightwire, slackrope, (etc) in that it uses a dynamic webbing. Although slackline webbing feels flat, and feels static when in your hands, it is actually a tube (that is stretched flat), and once you put your weight on it you can feel it is quite elastic.

There is some semantic discussion amongst slackers nowadays as to what constitutes “slackline” as more and more longline walkers switch to stronger (less stretchy materials). If nothing else, slackline is 1″ nylon tubular webbing. It may include a couple other types of webbing too, depending on how you look at the situation.

The table below contains a bunch of common webbings (closer to the top) and then newer “exotic” webbings being used for longlines and highlines. If the strength rating has an asterisk (*) that denotes that I am providing an actual tested strength that is LOWER than the manufacturer’s rating (as I would rather provide the least optimistic number). A tilde (~) denotes I have approximated a value.

Webbing Width Strength (LBS) Strength (KN) Weight (g/m & lb/100ft) Cost per foot
Mil-Spec 1″ 4000 17.4 40g / 2.7lb $.36
Climb-Spec 1″ 4270 19 41g / 2.8lb $.34
Tech Tape 1″ 4500 20 40g / 2.7lb $.39
Mil-Spec 2″ 6750 30 ~80g / ~5.4lbs $.65
Climb-Spec 9/16″ 2023 9 23.7g / 1.6lbs $.28
Climb-Spec 11/16″ 3000 13.3 ??? / ??? $.44
Type18 1″ 6000 (up to 7200) 27 (up to 32) 59g / 4.0lbs $.58
Gibbon ProLine 1″ 6000 27 85g / 5.76lbs $1.25
Vectran 1″ 12000 53 37.2g / 2.5lb ~$3.25
Mantra 1″ 9450 42 72g / 4.8lb ~$.80
Slackstar Distance 1″ 6000* 27* 59g / 4.0lbs ~$1.50
White Magic 1″ 5600* 25* 57g / 3.9lbs ~$1.50

MIL SPEC vs CLIMB SPEC
If you look at the image above, you will see the tennis-ball-yellow (this color is called “citrine”) webbing has prominent horizontal ridges, like a backpack strap, and the red/silver/purple/orange webbings are smoother in their weave. The ridged weave is military spec webbing, the smooth weave is climbing spec webbing. For the most part, military spec is easier to find, and in a larger variety of colors. REI only carries climb spec in khaki and purple. Other colors can be found in climb spec, but usually have to be ordered through an Internet vendor (or maybe your local indie climbing shop has them). For the most part these webbings are identical. Climb spec is something like 6% stronger (19Kn vs 17.8Kn). I use both. Bluewater makes the climb spec webbing commonly found (sometimes Sterling climb spec can also be found, and sterling has a special climb spec version that I have yet to try, called “tech tape” which will hold 20Kn).

9/16″ AND 11/16″
There are tubular webbings available in smaller sizes than 1″ — both 9/16 and 11/16 inch webbings are available, with 9/16 usually being easier to find (also called half-inch sometimes). 11/16 = 13.3Kn (3000lbs). 9/16=9Kn (2023lbs). Either of these webbings will probably hurt if you walk them barefooted, but in shoes they feel fine, and in general they stretch more than 1″, accentuating the “bounciness” of the slackline. I like to walk half inch because it’s fun for bounce and surf tricks, and it looks more like a “wire” to observers who don’t know what slackline is.

2″

Two inch tubular webbing is super strong (30Kn!), but doesn’t wrap well around carabiners because of its width (forget about primitive tightening, it won’t slip through the ‘biners), and it stretches very little. It’s great for jump lines, assuming you can pull it tight enough (ratchet, pullies, etc). Some specialized jump lines (like those from Gibbon) are not nylon tubular 2″ at all, but a flat polyester or similar.

THREADED LINES
One way of strengthening a line is to run a smaller line inside of it. In the image above you can see the red 9/16″ has been threaded inside of the silver 1″. The physics of this are still up for debate — certainly the two strengths are not just added together (!), but anecdotal evidence and pull tests show that threaded lines are stronger. As half inch is stretchier, there have been instances where the outer line breaks and the inner holds. Also, if the outer line frays, the inner will become visible, which can be a nice safety. Of course, threaded lines weigh about 50% more.

TYPE18
This is a flat (non-tubular) type of military webbing that is no longer made, but still available from some retailers. It’s approx 50% “thicker” than tubular 1″ but has the same 1″ width.  You can see it compared to mil-spec 1″ here and here. It weighs double that of tubular one inch, and offers a 6000lb (26.7Kn) break strength. Line locker pull tests done by others have shown it to break around 7200lbs, so it’s likely the 6000lbs is underrated. It stretches about half as much (9-10%) as tubular 1″ too, so keep that in mind. For normal walking it feels great, very supple, but for jumps and whatnot it is noticeably more ’static.’ This webbing works great for highlines, but beware of barehanded catches, it is known for bloody palms.  A word of warning: Type18 can be somewhat hard to find, is not cheap, and there are some retailers selling “knockoff” versions.  I buy mine directly from Yates.

Be aware, the info below applies to people who are rigging 100+ft lines.  On a short (30-60ft) line, any method is fine!

KNOTS
You’ll find there are several different ways to affix a line to another line, or a line to a carabiner.  The most basic is a knot, usually a waterknot.  A waterknot is just an overhand knot tied in two pieces of webbing, and they backtrace each other.  The larger the bend-radius of a knot, the stronger it is, so I sometimes insert a third 10″ piece of webbing to act as “filler.”  (see this pic for example)  Knots generally reduce line-strength to about 50-65% of rated.  If the line is tied in a loop (a “basket” configuration), the strength of the line is doubled, so overall you can expect at least 130% or so of the regular line’s rated strength.

LOCKERS
Line lockers are great — I swear by them.  They generally do not reduce the strength of the line significantly, so just make sure you use nice, fat, solid lockers.  That being said, it is possible to break/bend lockers.  I use a lot of steel rap rings as lockers, many of which I’ve sourced from one vendor.  These are supposed to be 10,000lbs break strength, yet loading a line with way less than 2000lbs of load, I was able to bend one of these rings close to failure; so watch your gear, double up for protection if possible, use backups, and tie things off so they can’t go flying. If you want to know more about line lockers (how to use them, which to buy, etc) … see this post.

STITCHING
A bartack is a type of burly industrial stitching used to fuse webbing to itself (or to other webbing). Each bartack can hold around 700lbs, in nylon webbing, meaning that a series of ten should be stronger than the webbing itself. I used to trust stitching more than any other solution, but recently I had a couple of bartacked lines nearly fail on me, and I have stopped trusting stitching that hasn’t been done (and tested) by large companies. I would still trust Petzl (etc) slings, as I know these companies randomly pull-test their products to ensure safety, but I am no longer trusting anything I’ve had custom made by small vendors. The stitching in question began to pull out at around 1500lbs of load. This is highly unsafe.

Just how much tension can you put in a slackline?
In the first of our tests, here’s adam putting 332lbs into a line barehanded, then ~450lbs with a carabiner for a handle, then almost 800lbs with two pulleys and some cord.

Responses

  1. carda says:

    July 13th, 2011 at 4:49 pm (#)

    Many thanks for sharing your experience here. I really respect it.

  2. Nuri says:

    August 24th, 2011 at 1:25 am (#)

    Hello Adam,
    First of all, Thanks a lot for your great work and sharing.
    I am living in Turkey and I dont have too many options for webbings to buy. Now i could find the white one of this webbing at my local store “edelrid 25 mm x-tube” (http://www.edelrid.de/en/sports/products/slings/25-mm-x-tube.html) but i could not find an information about the elasticity of the webbing. it says on the web site, this is perfectly suitable for the slackline but i want to buy about 250 feet for the longlines and highlines. Do you have any information about the streching percentage of this webbing or have you ever tried this?
    Thanks

    REPLY: Hi. The page you linked said it’s 43 grams per meter. Normal slackline webbing is 40 or 41 g/m, so that sounds like normal webbing to me. Also, the site you linked said 20KN strength, which is close to normal webbing.

    I like the look of this webbing, especially the “oasis-night” color. Anyway, it looks like normal nylon webbing to me, based on the ratings, albeit a different brand/color than I have ever seen. If I had to guess, I would say the typical max 20% stretch that nylon webbing has (before breaking) would be the same here. I do not believe this is polyester webbing (which stretches less). If you have any doubts, maybe buy a small piece and do some testing. Or if you want to mail me a one or two meter length I can break test it for you with a line locker to verify its strength (poly webbings break at very low numbers in line lockers or when knotted, so you must always use a zilla or banana or awl with them). If you can also buy the “supertape 16mm” you could thread that inside the 25mm webbing for a stronger line. I would be careful highlining on any webbing you do not know the characteristics of the line (e.g. nylon, poly) and what rigging equipment will work best with it.

    Also, as general highlining advice, don’t ever highline on a single line (always at least one backup); most people today are using stronger materials than normal tubular webbing. In years past doubled up tubular webbing (perhaps with a climbing rope beneath) was considered safe. Now in a quest for safer and lighter many people are moving to newer webbing types; Type18, vectran, Gibbon Proline, etc. I know of people who have highlined on single tubular with two thinner (15mm) lines threaded inside it, and that is another “reasonably safe” option.

    A 200-250ft piece should make a good longline, especially if you thread another line inside it. Looking on google at other places where people have reviewed it, it seems like normal climbing nylon webbing.

    Let me know how else I can help!

Leave a Response

 

Buying a slackline?

Here's what you need to know:

1: Make sure you protect the trees you attach to.

2: There are different "types" of slacklines with different "feel" ... choose one that is best for you!

3: Don't be afraid to get in contact if you get stuck!